Home › Claim Guides › Emergency Tarping & Mitigation
Emergency Tarping, Board-Up & Mitigation: What Insurance Owes and the Order of Operations
After storm, fire, or water damage, your policy obligates you to take reasonable steps to prevent further damage — and obligates your insurer to reimburse the reasonable cost of those steps: tarping, board-up, water extraction, temporary fencing. Photograph everything first, keep every invoice, and don't start permanent repairs until the damage has been inspected.
Why you can't just wait for the adjuster
Every property policy contains a duty, usually phrased as protecting the property from further damage and making reasonable and necessary temporary repairs. It cuts both ways. Meet it, and the emergency costs are part of your claim. Ignore it — leave the hole in the roof open through the next two rainstorms — and the carrier has an argument that the new water damage was preventable and isn't owed. In a wet week, an unprotected breach can turn a $30,000 roof claim into a contested mess of mold and ceiling collapses. The tarp is not optional; it's the cheapest insurance-claim decision you'll make.
What counts as reimbursable emergency work
- Roof tarping and shrink-wrapping over storm or fire breaches
- Board-up of broken windows, doors, and burned openings
- Water extraction and structural drying — pumps, dehumidifiers, air movers
- Temporary shoring or fencing where the structure or site is unsafe
- Moving contents out of harm's way, including short-term storage
- Materials you bought to do it yourself — tarps, plywood, fasteners
The measuring stick is reasonable: what a prudent owner would spend to stop the bleeding, at market rates. It is emergency protection, not the start of reconstruction.
The order of operations
- Safety. Downed lines, gas smell, structural sag — people first, property second.
- Photograph and video everything — wide shots and close-ups, inside and out — before anything is moved, covered, or cut. This is the single most important step on this page. Mitigation changes the scene; the pictures preserve it.
- Mitigate. Tarp, board, extract, dry. Same day if possible.
- Paper everything. Itemized invoices from any contractor; receipts for DIY materials; photos of the completed protection work.
- Notify your carrier promptly and tell them what emergency measures you took.
- Keep the evidence. Damaged materials and contents stay put (or bagged and stored) until inspected — unless they're a genuine health hazard, in which case photograph thoroughly and keep samples.
- Hold the line on permanent repairs. Nothing gets rebuilt, re-shingled, or re-sheetrocked until the damage has been inspected and documented. Permanent work done early destroys the proof of what happened.
Do it yourself or hire it out?
Materials for a self-done board-up or ground-reachable tarp are claimable — keep the receipts. But be honest about the roof: steep, wet, or anything above one story is how homeowners end up in the ER, and most of New York City's housing stock qualifies. For roof work and any real water event (a licensed mitigation company with drying logs and moisture readings is also building your evidence file), hire insured professionals. The cost is reimbursable either way; the hospital visit is not.
The contracts to be careful with
After every major storm, crews walk the affected blocks offering "free" tarps and instant sign-ups. Some are legitimate. Some hand you paperwork that assigns away your insurance benefits, locks you into that contractor for the full repair, or plants an inflated lien on the claim. Before signing anything on a clipboard the day after a loss: read what the document actually assigns, confirm the price for the emergency work in writing, and know that you — not the carrier, not the door-knocker — choose who repairs your property and who represents you on the claim. If a "free tarp" requires your signature on a repair contract, it isn't free.
What if the carrier won't reimburse the emergency work?
Push back on the standard, in writing: the policy required the protection, the cost was reasonable, and here are the invoices and photos. Disputes usually attack either necessity (your before-photos answer that) or price (comparable local invoices answer that). In New York, Regulation 64 governs claim-handling timelines — the carrier must acknowledge your claim within 15 business days and keep you informed in writing — so silence is something you can cite, not just endure. Emergency costs can also be supplemented later if they were incurred before the claim number even existed; pay-first does not mean waived.
The NYC wrinkles
Flat-roof rowhouses and party walls mean one building's breach becomes two buildings' water problem — coordinate with the attached neighbor and document the shared condition. Fire scenes may carry a Department of Buildings vacate order or emergency declaration; photograph any posted notices, since they matter for both the claim and your Additional Living Expenses. And if the damage came from a fallen tree, the removal invoice needs to be split a particular way — that's covered in the tree damage guide.
Emergency mitigation FAQ
Will insurance pay for a tarp before my claim is approved?
Yes. Reasonable emergency protection is reimbursable — and required by the policy. Keep itemized invoices and photograph before and after.
The tarp blew off and more rain got in. Is the new damage covered?
If your protection efforts were reasonable, storm-caused re-damage is part of the claim. Re-secure the opening, document the failure and the new damage, and report it. The standard is reasonable effort, not a guarantee against weather.
Can I throw away ruined belongings?
Photograph everything and keep items and material samples until the adjuster inspects, unless they're a genuine health hazard. Discarded and undocumented is the easiest denial there is.
Does tarping count as starting repairs or admitting anything?
No. Emergency protection is a policy duty — not a repair, not an admission. The line to respect is permanent repairs before inspection.
Can I tarp the roof myself?
If it's safely reachable, yes, and your material receipts are claimable. For steep, wet, or multi-story roofs, hire an insured contractor — reimbursable either way.
This guide describes standard policy forms in general terms. Your policy's specific language, limits, and endorsements control. This is general information, not legal advice.